Distinguished art historian Michael Baxandall here discusses the historical understanding of works of art – how we can discover the intentions of an artist living in. Patterns of Intention has ratings and 11 reviews. where I took a Graduate Seminar from the venerable art theoretician Michael Kighly Baxandall. The style. Krystal R. South Art History Methods Dr. Anne McClanan Winter, Patterns of Intention: On the Historical Explanation of Pictures It seems impossible to.
|Published (Last):||14 November 2014|
|PDF File Size:||13.34 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||3.56 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Baxandall draws a crucial distinction between art writing that tries to recount the stroke-by-stroke stages by which a painter creates a picture and art writing that uncovers the salient circumstances that shape the concrete intentions that produce artworks. To ask other readers questions about Patterns of Intentionplease sign up. Skip to main content.
Thornee rated it it was amazing May 05, And this is important because these non-visual assumptions about the significance—the meaning—of art also impinge on the marketplace, on taste culture and, by extension, on the problems artists pose and the solutions they develop.
On the Historical Explanation of Pictures”: This single location in Tasmania: Intwntion keywords specified fix it. Be the first to add this to a list. Kali Bazan rated it really liked it May 09, Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read. Cultural difference Knowledge of other cultures: But this freedom was not absolute, as Baxandall shows in Chapter 2, section 4; Picasso was, after all, a social being in cultural circumstances.
Michael Baxandall, Patterns of Intention: On the Historical Explanation of Pictures – PhilPapers
He will not consider cultures as having a uniform impact on individuals that participate in them. For ideas to function in this way, as part of our description of an artist’s brief, we do not need evidence that the artist actually thought about them that’s the point of the disclaimer that intentions are not “historical states of mind” but merely that they were such that the artist could have thought about them they form part of the relevant circumstances of the work.
The Forth Bridge a narrative. Painters and thought Vulgar Lockeanism and vision Og lady taking tea: Alessandro Pignocchi – – Philosophical Psychology 3: The first chapter, on the reading, viewing, and writing of an image, is both brilliant and elegantly written.
State Library of NSW. These online bookshops told us they have this item: But there is a difference between the sense of problem in the actor and in the observer. There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
The inferential critic who, once again, is interested in using precise descriptions of visual features of works to pose questions about causation should intenntion two assumptions: Sorting the causes of form.
The Art History of Michael Baxandall, Part 2: What is Inferential Criticism of Art?
But of what use is the idea of a Charge when trying to explain the paintings of Picasso, or, for that matter, the films of a Godard? There are also connotations of difficulty. Hopefully this review has been helpful. He makes a thorough case for this approach, but he leaves no space for the meaning of a work t Here, Baxandall attempts to make the study of painting legitimate by the standards of a historian, by attempting to deduce the cultural and historical reasons that a work of art looks a certain way i.
The idea that such appeals are illegitimate was part of a New-Critical move to establish the hegemony of one kind of reader, and one kind of reading, alone.
Defines and explains various concepts regarding the painter’s intentions in order to provide a basis for understanding of a work of art. A wonderful book for intentipn interested in art or art history and how the conventions, symbols, and interpretations change with time. My library Help Advanced Book Search. I now take on the mighty Patterns of Intention: Paul Roth – – Journal of the Philosophy of History 2 2: Not sure I got everything on first reading, but the first section contained some interesting thoughts that can be related to portraiture which is probably why Jonathan Weinberg recommended it to me a intentioh years ago, pre-doctoral.
On the Historical Explanation of Pictures.
These 4 locations in Western Australia: Broad Briefs appear to have less explanatory force if one is studying not a Picasso versus a Piero but two contemporaries. As such, he largely sidesteps the questions of interpretation in which I’m interested, and so, despite the clear style, this book bored me to tears.
Flinders University Central Library. The Shaw Research Library.
Patterns of Intention: On the Historical Explanation of Pictures – Michael Baxandall – Google Books
Varieties and Vagaries of Historical Explanation. Baxandall therefore fails to consider the implications of a basic fact of art history: Distinguished art pattedns Michael Baxandall here discusses the historical understanding of works of art – how we can discover the intentions of an artist living in a different time and culture and to what extent we can test and evaluate a historical interpretation of a picture.
Perhaps Baxandall would reply that this is not a problem, because then the explanation of the differences between two contemporary works would lie with more precise contextual considerations who, for instance, were the patrons, and did they have special demands?
Where Ethics and Aesthetics Meet: